Key Insights from USCIS Director at CIS Conversation
On September 4, the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) hosted an Immigration Newsmaker conversation featuring Joseph Edlow, the recently confirmed director of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). This event provided a platform for Edlow to outline his vision for the agency responsible for overseeing the nation's lawful immigration system. Having been confirmed by the U.S. Senate on July 15, 2025, with a vote of 52-47, Edlow brings a wealth of experience from his previous roles, including Acting Director of USCIS during the first Trump administration.
During the discussion, Edlow emphasized the need for reforms within the immigration system. He expressed concerns over issues such as immigration fraud, stating, 'More resources should be directed toward investigating immigration fraud.' This statement reflects his priority to enhance the integrity of the immigration process, a theme that resonated throughout the conversation moderated by CIS's Mark Krikorian.
Proposed Changes to Citizenship Tests and Visa Programs
One of the standout points from Edlow's talk was his critique of the current citizenship test. He argued, 'This test is just too easy... We need to make it a little more challenging... We're going to make the test harder in terms of making questions a little more thought-provoking.' This proposed change aims to ensure that applicants have a deeper understanding of American civics and history, aligning with his broader goal of strengthening the naturalization process.
Additionally, Edlow touched on visa programs, particularly those affecting American workers. He highlighted his concerns about student and work visas, noting, 'I think it's depressing wages, and it's something that we need to be concerned about.' His comments suggest a potential reevaluation of these programs to prioritize American labor interests, a stance that has sparked varied reactions among stakeholders in the immigration debate.
Edlow also addressed the backlog of immigration cases, asserting, 'There should be an end to those cases. That end is either them getting relief before an immigration judge or their ultimate removal from this country.' This firm position underscores his commitment to streamlining processes within USCIS to ensure efficiency and adherence to legal standards.
Public and Policy Implications of Edlow's Leadership
The conversation at CIS shed light on the direction USCIS might take under Edlow's leadership. With his background as a contributor to Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation's presidential transition plan, there is an expectation of significant policy shifts aimed at tightening immigration controls. His prior experience in various roles at USCIS and the Department of Justice positions him as a figure likely to push for stringent enforcement and policy reforms.
The public response to Edlow's appointment and subsequent statements has been mixed, as seen in various posts on social media platforms like X. While some applaud his focus on protecting American jobs and enhancing the integrity of the immigration system, others express concern over potential restrictions and the impact on immigrant communities. As USCIS moves forward under his direction, these discussions will likely continue to shape the national discourse on immigration policy.