Unexpected Retirement Shocks Colts Fans
Veteran cornerback Xavien Howard, at the age of 32, has stunned the Indianapolis Colts organization and its fanbase by announcing his retirement from the NFL. The decision came just days after a widely criticized performance against the Los Angeles Rams on September 28, where Howard struggled significantly in coverage. The Colts confirmed on October 1 that Howard had been placed on the reserve/retired list, marking the end of his brief stint with the team after only four games in the 2025 season.
Howard's retirement statement emphasized personal reasons for his departure. 'I'm putting my family first,' he stated, reflecting on a career that spanned nine years, predominantly with the Miami Dolphins before joining the Colts in late August. He also mentioned a newfound focus on faith, saying, 'I've had a hell of a career, but I'm no longer willing to put football over family,' signaling a shift in priorities after a challenging start to the season.
Struggles on the Field: A Tough Final Game
Howard's final game against the Rams highlighted significant difficulties in his performance, drawing intense scrutiny from analysts and fans alike. According to data from Pro Football Focus, Howard allowed seven receptions on nine targets for 112 yards and a touchdown, with a passer rating against of 155.6. Rams star receiver Puka Nacua capitalized on Howard's coverage issues, posting a career day with 13 receptions for 170 yards and a touchdown.
This subpar outing was part of a broader struggle during Howard's four games with the Colts, a stark contrast to his illustrious career achievements. A four-time Pro Bowler and a First-Team All-Pro in 2020 with the Dolphins, Howard had previously led the league in interceptions twice, showcasing his elite skills as a shutdown corner. However, his comeback attempt in 2025 after sitting out the 2024 season did not yield the expected results, culminating in his decision to step away.
Colts Move Forward: Replacing a Veteran Presence
With Howard's abrupt exit, the Colts are now tasked with filling the void left at the cornerback position. The team has already made moves to address the roster gap, signing safety Trey Washington to the 53-man roster and adding a new cornerback to the practice squad. Potential in-house candidates to replace Howard include Mekhi Blackmon, Mike Hilton, and Johnathan Edwards, as the team looks to stabilize its secondary opposite starter Charvarius Ward.
Howard's relationship with defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo, stemming from their time together with the Miami Dolphins, had initially fueled optimism about his fit with the Colts. However, after just four games, his retirement leaves the team searching for answers. As Indianapolis navigates this transition, Howard's legacy as a dominant NFL cornerback remains intact, even as his final chapter closes on an unexpected note.